01/11/Hans-Hermann Hoppe Democracy-The God that Failed is a brilliant and unflinching work that will be of intense interest to scholars and students of. Democracy: The God that Failed by Hoppe 12/04/Hans-Hermann Hoppe. The Economics and Politics of Monarchy, Democracy, and Natural Order. The God That Failed. The Economics and PoUtlcs of. Monarchy, Democracy, and Natural Order. Hans-Hermann Hoppe. Transaction Publishers.
|Published (Last):||3 April 2015|
|PDF File Size:||4.23 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||15.79 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Untersuchungen zur Grundlegung von Soziologie und Oekonomie Opladen: More and more programs that set up dangerous dependencies but also assured election and re-election of the patrons. By far the most off-putting aspects of the book, though, are some of Hoppe’s cultural arguments, particularly in the essays on immigration.
The facts do not provide an answer to such questions, and no amount of statistical manipulation of data can possibly change this fact. There are detailed explanations regarding the operation of a natural order as a state-less social system with freely financed insurance agencies serving as competitive providers of law and order. My highlighters got a workout. While he brings thought provoking evidence to this charge, I am not convinced that the noble experiment should be abandoned.
Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Hoppe provides a brilliant analysis of the western transformation from monarchy to democracy, shows that monarchy is a lesser evil than democracy but outlines the flaws in both systems, and provides a positive alternative — the idea of a natural aristocratic order and stateless society with a free-market responsible for the production of security.
The core of this book is a systematic treatment of the historic transformation of the West from monarchy to democracy.
Articles of Interest
Erik von Kuehnelt-Leddihn, Leftism Revisited. Jan 02, Thomas rated it it was ok. When in March the U. One of the most inspiring things I find about Hoppe’s writing is that we really don’t even need geographically defined free cities to consider if his ideas will be successful. Es handelt sich um eine weitgehend sachliche Analyse der Demokratie, auch wenn diese mit einer klaren politischen Haltung verbunden ist. Jul 04, Nathan rated it really liked it.
America’s Pyrrhic Victories New Brunswick: The public debt has risen everywhere to astronomical heights, in many cases exceeding a country’s annual Gross Domestic Product.
This is not a philosophical treatise devoted to tgat discussion of issues of epistemology and ontology.
When he does, it is generally more of an assertion that they are bad because they can exercise the power to tax and use force. Want to Read saving….
Hans-Hermann Hoppe – Wikiquote
Universal adult suffrage was introduced, and all government power was vested in parliaments and “public” officials. While history will play an important role, the following is not the work of a historian but of a political economist and philosopher, however.
An economic and political masterpiece! Only theory can again provide an answer, for theoretical propositions, as just illustrated, concern necessary facts and relations; and accordingly, just as they can be used to rule certain historical reports and interpretations out as false or impossible, so can they be used to rule certain other things in as constructively possible, even if such things have never been seen or tried. When the sovereign franchise is placed in the hands of the common person, he or she becomes a more responsible citizen, as they now have a voice in the running of the government.
I’ve actually just now read it after a personal departure from “pure” libertarian thought, and predictably found the bits about conservatism, aristocracy, and monarchy vastly more interesting than the bits that repeated the same ol’ AnCap talking points for the 6 millionth time although they’ll obviously be fresher to others.
The biggest “interesting” fact is that if you’re a business owner, then the set-in-place monarch will have more entrenched rules and that will let you better make time preference business decision. They are put together at 13 dif Expectedly, Hoppe does not hold back views that may rub people the wrong way. This notwithstanding, the following studies can in two regards claim originality.
That may or may not be true, but comparing alternative “bads” to determine which is less bad is an odd way to make an argument for a stateless society. But Hoppe doesn’t stop there. In Western Europe in particular unemployment rates have been steadily edging upward and are currently exceeding ten percent.
The old theory of democracy was that the “natural aristocrats” among people would raise the others up simply by the power of their good example. The United States produces more computers than any other country. In the first half, Hoppe argues that democracies introduce elements of decivilization and ultimately pave the way for barbarism.
Every topic while starting with legitimate arguments on a topic but takes logic too far to reach many a times slippery slope, ad absurdum indeed. Since he has an interest in keeping the value of the property up, he and his staff will be forward-thinking, and pass policies that will not wreck the economy because he will suffer as a result of this.
Near the end of the book he also makes the claim that conservatives can take hints from libertarians and vice versa and that the two ideologies go hand-in-hand. Hoppe leans into the idea of a “limited state” as anything enshrining liberty, I could almost hear the muffled cries of Rand, Nozick and Hayek as I absorbed the pages.
They are put together at 13 hopppe chapters. Not an easy read, very chewy ideas that require a fair bit of time to digest and sink in. So does Hoppe call for a return to monarchy? Lastly the footnotes should be footnotes and please have mercy on readers by not quoting Mises at every penultimate page.
In general he is a bit of a nasty elitist. The state, is by definition a territorial monopoly that exists exclusively through expropriation, where is the liberty? Such a state had to be shattered, such a dynasty had to disappear. Overall, this is a book that makes you think and may even change your mind on a thing or two.
The book is a must read for libertarians who want to poke holes in the logic and narratives of the establishment. I’m a firm believer in technology as the only route to achieving any kind of durable and lasting property protection through computing, cryptography, and at some point, the conquest of new physical hopoeand I don’t think Hoppe has particularly considered that.
Hoppe advocates for a natural order anarchy that is pioneered by small pockets of individuals who care not for the state’s control and seek to live in freedom. This book convinced me that the anarcho-capitalist idea of a tax-less society of private competing defense agencies is possible and may well be the ideal. In short, monarchical government is reconstructed theoretically as privately owned faailed, which in turn is explained as promoting future-orientedness and a concern for capital values and economic calculation by the government railed.